I've got a friend who recently began teaching English to high school students in San Francisco and is thinking of assigning graphic novels to his kids. Any suggestions?
Here's a little background: the guy teaches 9th and 10th grade English in one of those classic "inner city" schools full of under achievers. One class, in particular, is made up almost entirely of immigrant students who were either born in the US or immigrated as children. Their English is fluent, but at home they speak Chinese, Tagalog, or some other Asian language. The result is that their English skills, especially in the area of reading, are well below average.
To placate the African American sensibilities of some of the students, the prior teacher assigned the 1950s play, "A Raisin in the Sun" by Lorraine Hansberry. But it's so over the heads of most students that not only are they not making progress on the play's text, they wouldn't even sit still when my friend tried to get them to watch the play on video, promising that if they'd only sit through the damn thing, they wouldn't have to finish reading the written text. So you can see what he's up against.
I initially suggested that he try having the kids read Maus, but he said they've already done the Holocaust to death (no pun intended). Although I have not read it, I suggested Barefoot Gen, but he immediately vetoed it: being of non-Japanese extraction, these kids would have little empathy for Japanese travails in WWII, he said, since their parents and grandparents were the victims of the Japanese of that era.
I stopped by my local comic shop in Santa Cruz and took a brief gander at American Born Chinese -- I hope I have the title correct. What do people think of that? Are there any other suggestions?
And remember -- whatever gets suggested should be able to weather the scrutiny of a high school principal. The latest X-men extravaganza might not make the cut.
Graphic Novel recommendations for students?
|
By Alex Lint
Posted on: Nov 17th 2008 at 1:22 AM |
Replies: 7
|
Login to reply to this topic
Comments:
|
Posted by: Don Markstein
Posted on: 2008-11-17 at 06:09:40 AM
|
I suppose it's stereotyping to suggest that kids in California might respond to something of interest to Hispanics, but what about a couple of the Love & Rockets books? I respond to them myself.
And I'm sorry to hear Barefoot Gen has been rejected, but it certainly is not sympathetic to the warmongering rulers of Japan at the time. I think almost anybody could find sympathy for the family caught up in circumstances they can't control.
There are many excellent manga, but of course, there's that Japanese sensibility.
Of course, they don't have to be ethnic. (I hope!) I like newspaper strip reprints a lot. The staccato rhythm of a daily strip is very pleasing to me (personally). If the Li'l Abner books can still be found, they're of interest to all ages. Fantagraphics has a lot of good stuff in print, like Pogo and [/i]Prince Valiant.[/i] I'm a big fan of Little Orphan Annie, but I know some very intelligent people who can't stand it.
I'm not familiar with American Born Chinese, so I can't comment on it. A guy I used to be in contact with on another board did something called Secret Asian Man, but I don't know if it's available. The few samples I saw were pretty good.
Of course, Alan Moore is always a good bet, but Watchmen and From Hell might be a little over their heads. But how about Bill Willingham's Fables series? Seems like there must be one or two about Asian Fables, and I think they're probably age-appropriate. I'm also a big fan of his Proposition Player, if it can pass muster with the principal.
Not to get off on a personal hobby-horse, but maybe a guy in your position could help pressure DC into reprinting the original Amethyst, Princess of Genworld series in graphic novel form. That's an excellent one for teens.
These are just off the top of my head. I may have more suggestions after I've thought about it a little.
The quite proper rejection of the latest X-Men entry reminds me of when I was consulting with a local store about possibly selling graphic novels to libraries. They wanted me to stop recommending all that non-superhero stuff, because they were looking for "mainstream". But only in the woo-woo world of funnybook fans are superheroes the only thing that's "mainstream".
Well, this is an open topic. I hope others have suggestions.
Quack, Don
And I'm sorry to hear Barefoot Gen has been rejected, but it certainly is not sympathetic to the warmongering rulers of Japan at the time. I think almost anybody could find sympathy for the family caught up in circumstances they can't control.
There are many excellent manga, but of course, there's that Japanese sensibility.
Of course, they don't have to be ethnic. (I hope!) I like newspaper strip reprints a lot. The staccato rhythm of a daily strip is very pleasing to me (personally). If the Li'l Abner books can still be found, they're of interest to all ages. Fantagraphics has a lot of good stuff in print, like Pogo and [/i]Prince Valiant.[/i] I'm a big fan of Little Orphan Annie, but I know some very intelligent people who can't stand it.
I'm not familiar with American Born Chinese, so I can't comment on it. A guy I used to be in contact with on another board did something called Secret Asian Man, but I don't know if it's available. The few samples I saw were pretty good.
Of course, Alan Moore is always a good bet, but Watchmen and From Hell might be a little over their heads. But how about Bill Willingham's Fables series? Seems like there must be one or two about Asian Fables, and I think they're probably age-appropriate. I'm also a big fan of his Proposition Player, if it can pass muster with the principal.
Not to get off on a personal hobby-horse, but maybe a guy in your position could help pressure DC into reprinting the original Amethyst, Princess of Genworld series in graphic novel form. That's an excellent one for teens.
These are just off the top of my head. I may have more suggestions after I've thought about it a little.
The quite proper rejection of the latest X-Men entry reminds me of when I was consulting with a local store about possibly selling graphic novels to libraries. They wanted me to stop recommending all that non-superhero stuff, because they were looking for "mainstream". But only in the woo-woo world of funnybook fans are superheroes the only thing that's "mainstream".
Well, this is an open topic. I hope others have suggestions.
Quack, Don
|
Posted by: Rob Allen
Posted on: 2008-11-17 at 10:09:34 AM
|
I've heard good things about American Born Chinese but haven't actually read it, so I don't know if it would be good for this situation.
Most kids today, if they read any comics at all, it's manga. There's lots of manga that appeal to non-Japanese people. Maybe they could start with Shonen Jump and/or Shojo Beat magazines.
Another good resource would be the Community Forum at comicbookresources.com - several teachers and librarians post there, and they're happy to talk about what their students like.
Most kids today, if they read any comics at all, it's manga. There's lots of manga that appeal to non-Japanese people. Maybe they could start with Shonen Jump and/or Shojo Beat magazines.
Another good resource would be the Community Forum at comicbookresources.com - several teachers and librarians post there, and they're happy to talk about what their students like.
|
Posted by: Rob Allen
Posted on: 2008-11-17 at 12:06:36 PM
|
Forgot to mention - the African-Americans (and other baseball fans) might like Striking Out Jim Crow, which is about Satchel Paige. Here's a website about it:
[link:www.cartoonstudies.org]
And here's that address in plaintext, since this board's treatment of links is quirky:
www.cartoonstudies.org/books/paige/
There was also an award-winning graphic novel a couple of years ago about the legend and the reality of Stagger Lee. Not sure if that one is suitable for students.
[link:www.cartoonstudies.org]
And here's that address in plaintext, since this board's treatment of links is quirky:
www.cartoonstudies.org/books/paige/
There was also an award-winning graphic novel a couple of years ago about the legend and the reality of Stagger Lee. Not sure if that one is suitable for students.
|
Posted by: RedFive
Posted on: 2008-11-17 at 04:41:48 PM
|
I would recommend 'Pyongang' by Guy Delise. It's a well written account of the author's experience in the North Korean capital. Not a bad read since North Korea has been in the news lately.
I would also recommend some of Will Eisner's titles, particularly 'A Contract with God'. To me, Eisner had a talent of writing and illustrating an everyman persona, that is clearly evident in his work.
I would also recommend some of Will Eisner's titles, particularly 'A Contract with God'. To me, Eisner had a talent of writing and illustrating an everyman persona, that is clearly evident in his work.
|
Posted by: Don Markstein
Posted on: 2008-11-18 at 05:20:35 AM
|
Ooh, yeah! A Contract with God! But while I was worried about getting on a hobby-horse with Amethyst, I missed my favorite hobby-horse of all -- the fact that I'm firmly convinced Carl Barks was the greatest cartoonist of the 20th century, if not the greatest storyteller in any medium.
What was the name of the one were Scrooge goes to the land of Tralla-La? That's a good one, and it has the East Asian theme. Plus, there's a valuable lesson about the value of money that isn't based on intrinsic value, such as the dollars Washington is flooding Wall Street with, supposedly to stave off hard times but really to further enrich their already-wealthy cronies.
(I hope your teacher friend isn't put off by talking ducks, beause if you ignore their body types, Barks's characters are as human as anybody's, and more so than most.)
Quack, Don
What was the name of the one were Scrooge goes to the land of Tralla-La? That's a good one, and it has the East Asian theme. Plus, there's a valuable lesson about the value of money that isn't based on intrinsic value, such as the dollars Washington is flooding Wall Street with, supposedly to stave off hard times but really to further enrich their already-wealthy cronies.
(I hope your teacher friend isn't put off by talking ducks, beause if you ignore their body types, Barks's characters are as human as anybody's, and more so than most.)
Quack, Don
|
Posted by: Rob Allen
Posted on: 2008-11-21 at 03:44:51 PM
|
Just encountered this:
The Librarian's Guide to Graphic Novels for Children and Tweens
[link:www.neal-schuman.com]
That link again, in text:
www.neal-schuman.com/bdetail.php?isbn=9781555706265
The Librarian's Guide to Graphic Novels for Children and Tweens
[link:www.neal-schuman.com]
That link again, in text:
www.neal-schuman.com/bdetail.php?isbn=9781555706265
|
Posted by: Don Markstein
Posted on: 2008-11-22 at 07:50:58 AM
|
Sounds like a helpful suggestion, Rob. Thanks for making it.
Quack, Don
Quack, Don



